Call us today for an insurance quote!
(716) 876-7718

Pay A Bill

 

See below for a listing of all of our carriers and their mailing address\phone numbers for payment. Click on each company's image to access their online billing services.


The Hartford

Address:

PO Box 660916

Dallas, TX 75266-0916

Phone:

800-962-6170

 

Travelers

Address:

PO Box 660317

Dallas, TX 75266-0317

Overnight:

Attn: BI 660317

1500 Dragon St., Suite A

Dallas, TX 75207

Phone:

800-252-2268

 

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Address:

PO Box 2051

Keene, NH 03431-7051

Overnight:

62 Maple Ave.

Keene, NH 03431

Phone:

1-866-290-2920

 

Hanover Insurance Group

Address:

PO Box 580045

Charlotte, NC 28258-0045

Overnight:

c/o Branch Banking & Trust

Attn: Retail Lockbox 580045

5130 Parkway Plaza Blvd.

Charlotte, NC 28217

Phone:

800-573-1187

 

Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty

Address:

PO Box 550

Trumansburg, NY 14886

Phone:

800-724-4032

 

Erie & Niagara

Address:

PO Box 9062

Williamsville, NY 14231-9062

Phone:

800-234-9876

 

Dryden Mutual Insurance Co.

Address:

PO Box 635

Dryden, NY 13053

Phone:

800-694-8271

 

Main Street America Group

Address:

PO Box 2004

Keene, NH 03431-2054

Overnight:

Attn: Premium Services

100 West Street

Keene, NH 03431-3373

Phone:

1-877-927-5672

 

Foremost Insurance Group

Address:

PO Box 2487

Grand Rapids, MI 49501-2487

Phone:

1-855-325-2455 (Foremost policies)

1-855-866-6879 (Zurich policies)

 

ShelterPoint

Formerly First Rehab Life

Pay online (click on logo above)

Phone:

1-800-365-4999

 

National General Insurance

Formerly GMAC

Phone:

877-325-7727

 

Wesco Insurance Company

Formerly National Benefit Life

Pay online (click on logo above)

 

Philadelphia
Insurance Co

Address:

PO Box 70251

Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251

Overnight:

Attn: Cash Department

One Bala Plaza, Suite 100

Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004-0950

Phone:

1-877-438-7459

 

Preferred Mutual

Phone:

888-511-2455

 

Tower Group Companies

Phone:

877-883-6599

 

Progressive

Phone:

1-800-876-5581

 

Selective

Address:

PO Box 371468

Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468

Phone:

888-974-7400

 

Sterling Insurance Company

Address:

PO Box 9

Cobleskill, NY 12043

 

Utica National

Address:

PO Box 6532

Utica, NY 13504-6532

Overnight:

Attn: Credit & Collections

180 Genesee St.

New Hartford, NY 13413

Phone:

800-598-8422

 

MEMIC

Phone:

207-791-3391

 

NYCM Insurance

Also applies to A. Central Insurance policyholders

Address:

1899 Central Plaza East

Edmeston, NY 13335

Phone:

800-234-6926

 

Adirondack Insurance Exchange

Address:

PO Box 371898

Pittsburgh, PA 15251-7898

Phone:

877-365-8693

 

Safeco Insurance

Address:

PO Box 6476

Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476

Phone:

877-566-6001

 

Harleysville

Address:

Processing Center

PO Box 37712

Philadelphia, PA 19101-5012

Phone:

1-866-665-4992