Call us today for an insurance quote!
(716) 876-7718

Claim Contacts

 

See below for a list of claim phone numbers for each insurance company. Some carriers offer online claim reporting; click on the company logo if you wish to report your claim on their website. You can also call our office to report your claim; we are here to help!


The Hartford

Personal Auto & Homeowners:

1-800-243-5860

DBL:

1-800-303-9744

Commercial Auto, Property,

General Liability & Workers Comp:

1-800-327-3636

 

Travelers

Phone:

800-252-4633

 

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Phone:

800-362-0000

 

Hanover Insurance Group

Phone:

800-628-0250

 

Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty

Phone:

800-724-4032

 

Erie & Niagara

Phone:

800-234-9876

 

Dryden Mutual Insurance Co.

Phone:

800-782-0154

 

Main Street America Group

Phone:

877-425-2467

 

Foremost Insurance Group

For Foremost Policies:

800-435-7764

For Zurich Policies:

800-987-3373

Workers Compensation:

1-866-967-5256

ShelterPoint

Formerly First Rehab Life

Pay:

516-504-6414

Email (for forms):

1-800-365-4999

Email (for questions):

[email protected]

 

National General Insurance

Formerly GMAC

Phone:

1-800-325-1088

 

Wesco Insurance Company

Formerly National Benefit Life

Fax:

800-584-9308

Email: [email protected]

 

Philadelphia
Insurance Co

Phone:

1-800-765-9749

 

Preferred Mutual

Phone:

1-800-333-7642

 

Tower Group Companies

Phone:

877-856-5522

 

Progressive

Phone:

1-800-274-4499

 

Selective

Phone:

1-866-455-9969

 

Sterling Insurance Company

Phone:

800-462-4661

 

Utica National

Phone:

800-216-1420

 

MEMIC

Phone:

1-800-636-4292

 

NYCM Insurance

Also applies to A. Central Insurance policyholders

Phone:

800-234-6926

 

Adirondack Insurance Exchange

Phone:

877-365-8693

 

Safeco Insurance

Phone:

800-332-3226

 

Harleysville

Phone:

800-892-8877